DuckSouth.com

So far, he's the biggest one. Half of me wants to stick him, but cooler heads prevail, I'm thinking he needs another year or so. What do ya'll think, I have one buck, eerily similar to this guy, constantly arguing with myself that he either is the same or is not. Will try to post that pic up later.

Agreed. It's hard when you don't have any mature deer on camera, but they will show up. If you can stand to let him live, he will be real good next year.

Not exactly sure what you're looking for man, but that deer is every bit of 4 1/2 yrs old, and a 4 1/2 yr old is a dead deer in my book!

He's a dead deer in my neck of the woods or shot at deer shall I say!

He may even be 5. Choot him!!

he'd be down like four flat tires if it were me

Shoot the one with spots it taste better

I agree everyone. But I'm kind of with LawDog too, he'd be a helluva one in another year, problem is this, neighbors don't have restraint.

If neighbor has no restraints you better not either or u will be going to his camp to see your dead deer. Shoot him that's a fine deer

that is a mature deer i would say stick him. Look at his chest and stomach

CHOOT'em Lizabeth!!!!!!!!!!!! Choot'm!

If he's on a small piece of land that you have and the neighbors have no restraint, kill him. Look at that ole belly and it's mid-august

great buck

he would get shot at Hostile Acres Huntin Club for sure! The doe too for that matter!

I just noticed the fawn running through the picture.


He's 4.5 shoot him.